All states›Custom-Cut Butcher Shops›Indiana

Custom-Cut Butcher Shops in Indiana

21 of the 546 butcher shops, meat markets and specialty food stores we track in Indiana have custom cutting. Full listings for every city are on the Indiana page.

21shops
18cities
546shops statewide

A butcher shop's map listing usually just says "butcher shop" or "meat market," with no way to tell whether the shop cuts meat to order or only sells pre-packaged cuts from the case — that distinction lives on the shop's own site or a sign in-store, not in any searchable field. Every shop on this page has custom cutting confirmed directly from the butcher's own website or posted services.

Indianapolis 2

  1. Saraga International Grocery

    8448 Center Run Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46250

    Custom cutsHalal
    Call Website All Indianapolis

  2. Don's Butcher Shop

    8028 S Emerson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46237-8670

    Custom cutsLocal farms
    Call Website All Indianapolis

La Porte 2

  1. Sims Meat Processing

    6961 S 3rd Line Rd, La Porte, IN 46350-6546

    Custom cutsGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All La Porte

  2. I Street Meats

    1602 I St, La Porte, IN 46350-5749

    Custom cuts
    Call Website All La Porte

Wakarusa 2

  1. Martin's Custom Butchering

    27570 County Road 42, Wakarusa, IN 46573-9717

    Mon-Thu 7am-5pm, Fri 8:30am-6pm, Sat 8:30am-12pm

    Custom cutsLocal farms
    Call Website All Wakarusa

  2. ELM Custom Processing

    30425 Co Rd 36, Wakarusa, IN 46573

    Mon 7am-5pm, Tue 7am-5pm, Wed 7am-5pm, Thu 7am-5pm, Fri 7am-5pm

    Custom cuts
    Call Website All Wakarusa

Albion 1

  1. Pork 'N Cleaver

    4461 S State Road 9, Albion, IN 46701-9153

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausageLocal farms
    Call Website All Albion

Celestine 1

  1. Sander Processing

    6614 E State Road 164, Celestine, IN 47521

    Mon-Fri 7am-5pm, Sat 8am-12pm

    Custom cutsGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All Celestine

Columbus 1

  1. White Star Meat Market & Deli

    410 Washington St, Columbus, IN 47201-6758

    Mon-Sat 10am-6pm

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausage
    Call Website All Columbus

Corydon 1

  1. First Capitol Meats Corydon

    420 Higdon St, Corydon, IN 47112-1608

    Sat 9am-12pm

    Custom cutsGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All Corydon

Decatur 1

  1. Manley Meats, Inc

    302 S County Road 400 E, Decatur, IN 46733-9095

    Mon-Fri 8am-5pm, Sat 8am-12pm

    Custom cutsGame processing
    Call Website All Decatur

Ferdinand 1

  1. Ferdinand Processing & Catering

    1182 E 5th St, Ferdinand, IN 47532-9780

    Mon,Wed-Fri 7:30am-5pm, Tue,Sat 7:30am-12pm

    Custom cutsGame processing
    Call Website All Ferdinand

Fort Wayne 1

  1. Hill's Meat Market

    3203 Lower Huntington Rd, Fort Wayne, IN 46809-2443

    Mon-Fri 7:30am-7pm, Sat 7:30am-6pm

    Custom cutsDry-aged beefLocal farms
    Call Website All Fort Wayne

Greenfield 1

  1. Maxwell Meats & Processing

    228 N Main St, Greenfield, IN 46154-9701

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausageGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All Greenfield

Hammond 1

  1. Meats By Linz

    628 E Hoffman St, Hammond, IN 46327-1570

    Custom cutsGame processing
    Call All Hammond

Muncie 1

  1. Fisher Meats

    2800 N Walnut St, Muncie, IN 47303-1961

    mon-fri 8am-5pm

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausageGame processing
    Call Website All Muncie

Nappanee 1

  1. John's Butcher Shop

    158 N Main St, Nappanee, IN 46550-1938

    Tue-Fri 9:30am-5:30pm, Sat 8:30am-12:30pm

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausageGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All Nappanee

Spencer 1

  1. Rice's Quality Meats

    1294 Freeman Rd, Spencer, IN 47460-7427

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausageGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All Spencer

St Anthony 1

  1. Sander Family Meat Market

    4650 S Cross St, St Anthony, IN 47575-9640

    monday - friday: 7:00am - 5:00pm

    Custom cutsGame processing
    Call Website All St Anthony

Westport 1

  1. Sugar Rock Farms Meat Processing

    707 S West St, Westport, IN 47283-9116

    Custom cutsGame processingLocal farms
    Call Website All Westport

Zanesville 1

  1. Lengerich Meats Inc

    3095 Van Horn St, Zanesville, IN 46799-9027

    mon - thu : 9am - 5pm

    Custom cutsHouse-made sausageGame processing
    Call Website All Zanesville
Call ahead with your specs — thickness, bone-in or boneless, portion size — especially for larger or specialty orders. Custom cuts, whole animals, or holiday orders like a whole turkey or prime rib often need a few days' notice, so don't expect same-day service for anything out of the ordinary.

Also in Indiana

Good to know

What does "custom cuts" mean at a butcher shop?

It means the butcher will cut meat to your specifications — a particular thickness, bone-in versus boneless, or a specific portion size — rather than just selling pre-cut packages from the display case. Many custom-cut butchers can also break down a whole animal or fill special orders if you ask ahead.

Do I need to order custom cuts in advance?

For simple requests like a thicker steak, many butchers can cut it while you wait. For larger orders — a whole animal, a large holiday roast, or bulk freezer packages — it's common to need a few days' notice so the shop can plan for it.

What is hanging weight?

Hanging weight is the weight of a slaughtered animal after skinning and evisceration, but before final trimming and dry aging. When purchasing a side or whole animal in Indiana, local processors charge based on this weight. Browse 21 meat processors across Indiana on ButcherAtlas to learn more about custom carcass purchasing.

How to make sausage at home?

To make sausage at home, chill high-fat meat and grind it, mix thoroughly with seasonings and ice water until sticky, then stuff into natural casings. Keep all equipment cold to preserve the emulsion and texture. For custom meat grinds and fresh casings, visit any of the 21 specialized meat markets listed across Indiana on ButcherAtlas.