Selection styles vary widely between standalone cut-to-order counters, farmstead dairies focused on single-producer wheels, and wine shops with curated cheese cases. A map pin shows location, but it will not tell you whether a shop lets you sample before buying, stocks imported raw-milk varieties, or sells pre-cut wedges for quick pickup.
-
Agape Graze
1401 N Boeke Rd, Evansville, IN 47711
-
Agape Graze
122 N Weinbach Ave, Evansville, IN 47711-6006
-
Tulip Tree Creamery
6330 Corporate Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46278
Mon–Fri 9am–3pm
-
The Cheese Shop
8487 Union Chapel Rd Ste 300, Indianapolis, IN 46240
Auburn 1
-
The Cheesemanstore
1343 S Jackson St, Auburn, IN 46706-2815
Berne 1
-
Swissland Cheese Co
4310 S US Highway 27, Berne, IN 46711-9622
Billville 1
-
Bits-N-Bites Brazil IN
East National Ave, Billville, IN
Cambridge City 1
-
Amish Cheese Shop
2001 N State Road 1, Cambridge City, IN 47327
Griffith 1
-
The Atlas Room
128 N Broad St, Griffith, IN 46319-2265
Madison 1
-
Cheesy Come, Cheesy Go
719 W Main St, Madison, IN 47250
-
Heritage Ridge Creamery
11275 W 250 N, Middlebury, IN 46540
Also in Indiana
- Butcher Shops308
- Specialty Food Stores181
- Deer & Game Processing34
- Delis22
- Custom-Cut Butcher Shops21
Good to know
Can you sample cheeses before buying?
Most full-service, cut-to-order cheese shops allow customers to taste pieces before committing to a weight. Pre-packaged retail displays or smaller specialty markets generally do not offer samples unless they are hosting a scheduled tasting event.
What is the difference between farmstead cheese and artisan cheese?
Farmstead cheese is made on the same property where the milk-producing animals are raised, using only milk from that specific herd. Artisan cheese refers to cheeses made in small batches using traditional methods, but the cheesemaker may purchase milk from outside farms.
How much cheese should you buy per person for a platter?
For a casual board served alongside other snacks, plan on two to three ounces of cheese per guest. If the cheese board is the main food item for a gathering, aim for four to six ounces per person across three to five distinct varieties.
What is hanging weight?
Hanging weight is the weight of a slaughtered animal after skinning and evisceration, but before final trimming and dry aging. When purchasing a side or whole animal in Indiana, local processors charge based on this weight. Browse 11 meat processors across Indiana on ButcherAtlas to learn more about custom carcass purchasing.
How to make sausage at home?
To make sausage at home, chill high-fat meat and grind it, mix thoroughly with seasonings and ice water until sticky, then stuff into natural casings. Keep all equipment cold to preserve the emulsion and texture. For custom meat grinds and fresh casings, visit any of the 11 specialized meat markets listed across Indiana on ButcherAtlas.