Custom-Cut Butcher Shops in New York

21 of the 931 butcher shops we track in New York have custom cutting. A butcher shop's map listing usually just says "butcher shop" or "meat market," with no way to tell whether the shop cuts meat to order or only sells pre-packaged cuts from the case — that distinction lives on the shop's own site or a sign in-store, not in any searchable field. Every shop on this page has custom cutting confirmed directly from the butcher's own website or posted services. Full listings for every city are on the New York page.

Brooklyn 2

Polam Meat Market Inc Custom cuts

952 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222-5916

🕒 MONDAY 8AM-6PM

+17186090549 Website All Brooklyn butcher shops

Romeo Meats Custom cutsHouse-made sausage

7801 15th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11228-2513

🕒 Sun 8AM-2PM

+17183315911 Website All Brooklyn butcher shops

New York 2

Columbia Meat Market Custom cuts

437 Jersey St, New York, NY 10301-2924

+17184471744 Website All New York butcher shops

Leonard's Seafood and Prime Meats Custom cutsDry-aged beefLocal farms

1437 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10021-3310

🕒 Mon-Fri 8am-7pm

+12127442600 Website All New York butcher shops

Astoria 1

International Meat Market Custom cuts

36-12 30th Ave, Astoria, NY 11103

+17186266656 Website All Astoria butcher shops

Babylon 1

Babylon Village Meat Market Custom cutsDry-aged beef

85 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702-2801

+16316690612 Website All Babylon butcher shops

Bayville 1

Bayville Meat Center Custom cutsHouse-made sausage

282 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709-1693

+15166282139 Website

Beacon 1

Barb's Butchery Custom cutsHouse-made sausageLocal farms

69 Spring St, Beacon, NY 12508-3447

+18458318050 Website All Beacon butcher shops

Bethlehem 1

Van Allen Farms Custom cutsHouse-made sausage

806 US-9W, Bethlehem, NY 12077

+15187679101 Website

Edmeston 1

Farmers Place Custom cutsHouse-made sausageLocal farms

256 County Highway 20, Edmeston, NY 13411-7200

🕒 Mon-Fri 7am-4pm, Sat 8am-1pm

+16078478234 Website

Gates 1

Butchers BluePrint Custom cutsHouse-made sausage

2344 Lyell Ave, Gates, NY 14606-5738

+15853406007 Website

Hempstead 1

Anteri's Meat Market Custom cutsLocal farms

747 Hempstead Tpke, Hempstead, NY 11010-4329

🕒 Mon-Sat 8am-6:30pm, Sun 8am-2:30pm

+15165383509 Website All Hempstead butcher shops

Huntington 1

R and S Meat Market Custom cutsDry-aged beefHouse-made sausage

212 Wall St, Huntington, NY 11743-2094

🕒 Wed-Sat 10am-5pm

+16313511651 Website All Huntington butcher shops

Jamestown 1

Moon Meadow Farm LLC Custom cutsDry-aged beefLocal farms

2929 Moon Rd, Jamestown, NY 14701-9693

+17166134321 Website

Liverpool 1

Mazzye's Meats Custom cuts

7252 Oswego Rd, Liverpool, NY 13090-3719

🕒 Mon-Sat 8am-6pm, Sun 9am-2pm

+13154573697 Website

Lowville 1

Miller's Meat Market Custom cutsHouse-made sausageGame processing

6525 Number Four Rd, Lowville, NY 13367-3223

🕒 Mon-Fri 8am-5:30pm, Sat 8am-5pm

+13153766253 Website All Lowville butcher shops

Monticello 1

Carmine's Meat Market Custom cutsHouse-made sausage

36 Forestburgh Rd, Monticello, NY 12701-1833

+18457946328 Website All Monticello butcher shops

New Hyde Park 1

Andy's New Hyde Park Meats Inc. Custom cuts

1101 Jericho Tpke, New Hyde Park, NY 11040-4611

15163545970 Website

South Glens Falls 1

Monahan Custom Cut Meats & Smokehouse Custom cuts

67 Main Street , South Glens Falls, NY 12803

+15184094620 Website

Staten Island 1

Granite Fine Foods, Inc. Custom cuts

437 Jersey St, Staten Island, NY 10301-2924

+17184471744 Website All Staten Island butcher shops

Woodbury 1

Prime Time Butcher Custom cutsDry-aged beef

8045 Jericho Tpke, Woodbury, NY 11797-1212

+15169216519 Website

Call ahead with your specs — thickness, bone-in or boneless, portion size — especially for larger or specialty orders. Custom cuts, whole animals, or holiday orders like a whole turkey or prime rib often need a few days' notice, so don't expect same-day service for anything out of the ordinary.